An Oregon man on Thursday was ordered to spend 30 years in prison for fatally stabbing a beloved South Jersey veterinarian at his Cherry Hill home.
Read more In its second season, HBO’s ‘Task’ will see a crossover with ‘Mare of Easttown’
Cristian Custodio-Aquino, 28, of Portland, pleaded guilty to first-degree murder in June for the killing of 45-year-old Michael Anthony.
The body of Anthony, a divorced father of two, was discovered on the front lawn of his home in Cherry Hill’s Barclay Farm section in December 2024.
He had been stabbed in the body, neck, and head. Detectives used a variety of methods to link Custodio-Aquino to the crime, including the collection of DNA from a pair of prescription eyeglasses he had left at the crime scene.
During Custodio-Aquino’s sentencing before Camden County Superior Court Judge Judith Charny, Anthony’s family members spoke tearfully of late veterinarian, who they described as kind, wickedly funny, and a devoted father to his sons.
Above all, they grappled for answers as to why Custodio-Aquino murdered Anthony that morning on his front lawn.
“You took all of the future moments that should have belong to him,” said Patricia Anthony Gershefski, one of Anthony’s sisters.
Anthony Gershefski said her brother was warm and sensitive, even moving his veterinarian practice just to be closer to his children.
The brutal nature of the crime confounds the family to this day.
In her career as a professional psychologist, Anthony Gershefski said, she has found “no diagnostic category for the deliberate destruction of another person’s life in this savage and grotesque manner.”
Kyle Bartsch, Anthony’s partner, said in a statement read by prosecutors that Anthony had filled their home on Sharrowvale Road with love and laughter.
His death, Bartsch said, leaves “a permanent void in the lives of those who knew him.”
Read more Colwyn couple starved and neglected a woman with Down syndrome who was in their care, DA says
While Custodio-Aquino’s attorneys had previously suggested that prosecutors did not have enough evidence to convict their client of murder, they were mum throughout the proceeding.
In addition to the eyeglasses investigators linked to the Peru native, license plate readers captured Custodio-Aquino’s car entering and exiting Anthony’s neighborhood that morning, and forensic experts later recovered a sample of the veterinarian’s blood from the vehicle.
Prosecutors believe Custodio-Aquino traversed the country in a fit of jealousy that fall before killing Anthony.
He had previously dated Anthony’s partner, Bartsch, and once lived with the man in Haddon Township before the couple separated in 2021 after a domestic dispute, according to prosecutors.
Custodio-Aquino, given the opportunity to address the court, spoke so softly that Charny asked that he repeat himself.
Raising his voice, he said: “I do agree that the world is less than without Michael Anthony.”
He was sentenced to 30 years in a state correctional facility without parole. Charny offered few words on the ruling beyond wishing Custodio-Aquino good luck.
It was Henry Anthony, Anthony’s teenage son, who saved some of the most biting remarks for his father’s killer.
“Your life is officially over,” Anthony said, turning to look at Custodio-Aquino. “I honestly wonder what your reason for living will be for the next 30 years.”
Read more Future of Centre Square is uncertain again as rival developers question purchase