Convicted former Philadelphia labor leader John Dougherty will remain in prison after a federal judge again denied Dougherty’s request to be released on house arrest to provide care for his gravely ill wife.
Read more A nonfunctioning grenade was thrown into a Hunting Park home. The bomb squad safely removed it.
U.S. District Judge Jeffrey L. Schmehl wrote in a memorandum filed Thursday that Dougherty and his lawyers had failed to demonstrate that he was the only person who could provide adequate care for his wife, Cecelia, who for years has suffered from a debilitating brain injury.
In addition, Schmehl wrote, Dougherty did not sufficiently specify when a trust fund established to support his wife’s care would run out of money. Those factors, coupled with the “minimal amount of time” Dougherty has served in his six-year sentence, Schmehl wrote, “do not weigh sufficiently in favor of relief.”
The decision was a blow to Dougherty, 66, who for months has been contending in court documents and in testimony before Schmehl that his wife’s condition has significantly worsened while he has been imprisoned, and that if he isn’t released to care for her, she’ll likely die.
Dougherty’s attorney, George Bochetto, said in an interview Thursday that he was “deeply, gravely disappointed” by the ruling, and that he disagreed they hadn’t shown the acute nature of the emergency that should qualify Dougherty for release.
“I thought the evidentiary hearing we had in front of Judge Schmehl was extraordinary, and it left no doubt in anybody’s mind” about the merits of Dougherty’s petition, Bochetto said.
The ruling followed another denial in Dougherty’s ongoing bid for freedom. Earlier this month, President Donald Trump denied Dougherty’s request for a commutation, a legal avenue that could have cut Dougherty’s prison term short.
Schmehl, in his memorandum, did say that Dougherty could file a renewed motion in the future, “should the facts materially change.”
Bochetto said he would not wait that long. He was already working on his notice of appeal to the Third Circuit, he said, and he intended to ask the court to consider the case on an emergency basis.
“This is why God invented appellate courts,” Bochetto said.
Dougherty was sentenced in 2024 to six years in prison after being convicted in separate bribery and embezzlement trials that centered around actions he took while serving as the head of his politically powerful union, Local 98 of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers.
But last year, Dougherty — known colloquially as Johnny Doc — filed emergency motions asking Schmehl to allow him to serve the remainder of his prison term on house arrest in order to be his wife’s primary caretaker.
Read more Try a New Zealand sauvignon blanc that shows why Kiwis took the wine world by storm
In his first request, filed in the summer, Dougherty said the trust fund established to pay for her care was about to run out of money, and that his daughters and other relatives were unable to provide the kind of round-the-clock assistance she needed.
Then, in December, he filed another motion saying the situation had become more dire after the death of his father-in-law, who had been serving as the primary caregiver in his absence.
Prosecutors opposed Dougherty’s requests, saying that although they were sympathetic to his wife’s plight, they did not believe he had served enough of his sentence to merit release.
And in January, Schmehl denied Dougherty’s request, writing that he, too, recognized the significant health challenges, but that they did “not outweigh, at this point in time, the need for punishment that has been adjudged.”
Bochetto appealed that ruling. And in May, Schmehl held an evidentiary hearing to learn more.
At the hearing, Dougherty took the stand for more than an hour, and occasionally choked back tears as he described his wife’s myriad complications and detailed the efforts he’d made in prison to help her, including by sending her dozens of letters and using all of his allotted monthly phone minutes to call her.
But prosecutors argued that Dougherty and his relatives had not sufficiently looked into alternative care arrangements that might be covered by Medicaid or other insurance. And they said that while many families across the country could benefit from having an incarcerated defendant released to help care for their relatives, Dougherty had not shown that he was the only person who could do so for his wife.
Schmehl, in his order, said Dougherty’s wife is being cared for by private nurses and her two daughters, and that “neither party suggests that her current care is inadequate.” Beyond that, the judge said, Dougherty did not sufficiently specify when her trust fund would run out money, and did not adequately explain what would happen once it did.
The ruling will leave Dougherty, for now, to serve out the remainder of his term, which he’s serving at a federal prison in Lewisburg, Pa. His projected release date is in June 2029, according to the Bureau of Prisons website.
Read more A psychiatrist’s sexual misconduct | Morning Newsletter